Free in your browser: practice shot placement in Buck Hunt TrainerPlay now →
Buck Stalker
Archery

The 5 top-rated broadheads

· rankings checked November 18, 2026

This page contains affiliate links. If you buy through them, Buck Stalker may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate, Buck Stalker earns from qualifying purchases. Details.

The broadhead does the real work on a deer, so it has to fly with your field points and cut a wide enough channel for a short tracking job. The main trade-off is fixed blades, which are simple and durable, against mechanicals, which fly more like field points but rely on blades opening on impact.

What to look for

  • Match grain weight to your arrows or bolts, typically 100 or 125 grains, so your tuning and sight marks hold.
  • Use crossbow-specific heads on a crossbow, since they are built for higher speeds.
  • Practice with broadheads before the season to confirm they group with your field points.
  • Weigh cutting diameter against penetration, especially with lower draw weights.
  • Check your state's regulations, as some set minimum cutting widths or restrict mechanical broadheads.

The top 5, best first

  1. Rage Crossbow X 2-Blade Mechanical Broadhead, 100 Grain, 3 Pack

    Rage · highest rated

    A rear-deploying two-blade mechanical head for crossbows with a listed 2-inch cutting diameter and .035-inch stainless steel blades. A shock collar holds the blades closed in the quiver and in flight, then releases on impact. It is a 100-grain head made in the USA, with a 125-grain version also offered.

    Best for: Crossbow hunters wanting a large cutting diameter

    See price and reviews on Amazon
  2. G5 Montec Fixed-Blade Broadhead, 3 Pack

    G5 Outdoors

    A one-piece, all-steel fixed broadhead made by metal injection molding, with each head listed as spin-tested for balance. The cut-on-contact design has a listed cutting diameter of 1 to 1.125 inches, and it is offered in 85, 100 and 125 grains. This listing is the pink color option.

    Best for: Vertical bow hunters who want a durable fixed head

    See price and reviews on Amazon
  3. Muzzy Trocar Crossbow Fixed-Blade Broadhead

    Muzzy

    A fixed-blade Trocar broadhead made for crossbows, produced in the USA by Muzzy, a company founded in 1984. The listing offers few details on grain weight, blade count or cutting diameter, so confirm specifications before matching it to your bolts.

    Best for: Crossbow hunters who prefer fixed blades

    See price and reviews on Amazon
  4. Muzzy Trocar HBX Hybrid 4-Blade Crossbow Broadhead, 100 Grain

    Muzzy

    A hybrid crossbow head with two fixed blades and two mechanical blades, a chisel tip and a stainless steel ferrule. The fixed blades are offset to help spin the bolt in flight. It is listed at 100 grains in a three-pack.

    Best for: Combining fixed-blade reliability with extra mechanical cut

    See price and reviews on Amazon
  5. NAP Spitfire 3-Blade Crossbow Mechanical Broadhead, 3 Pack

    New Archery Products

    A front-deploying three-blade mechanical head for crossbows with a slim grooved ferrule and Diamize-sharpened blades. A spring clip keeps the blades closed without rubber bands or O-rings, and the Trophy Tip point is listed for crossbows up to 350 feet per second.

    Best for: Crossbows shooting up to 350 feet per second

    See price and reviews on Amazon

How this list was made

We searched Amazon for broadheads on November 18, 2026 and ranked the matching products by their Amazon customer star rating, highest first. Only products with at least 1,000 customer ratings were counted, so a product with a handful of perfect reviews can't outrank one that thousands of hunters have rated. Ties went to the product with more ratings, and no brand gets more than two places, so pack sizes and colors of one product don't fill the list. The descriptions are our own summaries of each product's listing; we haven't tested these products ourselves. Ratings and prices change, so check the current ones on Amazon.

More archery